Skip to content
Fish, Ink
All insightsHigher Education

The discovery that discoveries should do something

18 November 2026 · 5 min · Patrick Fish

The discovery that discoveries should do something

The discovery that discoveries should do something

The EDHE webinar From Research to Impact confronted a disturbing possibility: somewhere in South Africa, excellent university research might be sitting on a shelf, perfectly cited and entirely unused. It had survived peer review, satisfied its funding conditions and contributed handsomely to a promotion application. Unfortunately, nobody outside the university had found a reason to touch it.

This describes an approximately two-hour gathering devoted to correcting this unfortunate separation between knowledge and usefulness. Professor Evelyn Derera directed proceedings, Dr Edwell Gumbo offered the welcome, and Ms Pearl Maphumulo moderated. Researchers, government, industry and investors were present: almost everyone necessary to change the world, provided someone could establish who owned the change.

The central proposition was admirably simple. Research should become products, services, enterprises and social improvements. Its simplicity was also the problem. Once translated into institutional language, it required intellectual property advice, ownership agreements, market analysis, commercial capacity, adoption partners and another webinar.

Publish or perish, but kindly consult Legal first

Academics have traditionally been instructed to publish or perish. The webinar introduced an important qualification: publish too enthusiastically and the commercial prospects of your invention may perish instead.

Dr Outule Rapuleng explained that public disclosure could compromise opportunities for protection. Journal articles, conference presentations, posters, websites and social media all featured among the possible hazards. The researcher must therefore communicate knowledge energetically enough to maintain a career, but cautiously enough to preserve whatever commercial rights might make that career useful to somebody else.

Imagine the triumphant discovery announcement: years of work have finally produced a breakthrough, and the first congratulatory response is a request to stop talking. The laboratory celebrates in a spirit of strictly confidential joy.

The practical advice was sound: consult the technology transfer office early. The institutional comedy lies in a system that rewards visibility while requiring a strategically managed period of invisibility. Your work must be internationally recognised, but preferably not until the appropriate person has reviewed the abstract.

3. Intellectual property: the mind acquires a reception desk

Rapuleng distinguished patents, trademarks, copyright, industrial designs and utility models. This was useful because “I have an idea” is not, by itself, a complete legal strategy, however confidently delivered at a networking breakfast.

Patents concern qualifying inventions, trademarks distinguish goods and services, and industrial designs protect appearance. Bottled water supplied an accessible illustration of design’s commercial significance: humanity can spend considerable effort choosing the most persuasive container for essentially the same drink.

Patent protection was also described as territorial. An invention may have global ambitions; its paperwork has a more local outlook. Crossing a border does not automatically bring your rights along, like an obedient suitcase.

The wider landscape included CIPC, NIPMO, ARIPO, WIPO and TRIPS. For the newcomer, the route from inspiration to enterprise can resemble an alphabet escaping from a filing cabinet. Nevertheless, the point was not that innovation requires mastery of every acronym. It was that enthusiasm benefits from someone who knows which office to telephone.

Congratulations on your invention. Please meet its owner

Dr Ncebakazi Galada addressed the delicate moment when a student discovers that university ownership may apply to work the student quite distinctly remembers doing.

The emotional sequence is easy to imagine. First comes pride, then commercial ambition, then an institutional policy explaining that the relationship between effort, inventorship and ownership is more complicated than anticipated. Suddenly, the student becomes intensely interested in documents previously regarded as registration-season wallpaper.

Galada’s explanation was more reassuring than the panic suggests. Inventor recognition and institutional ownership are not identical; universities may also bear substantial protection costs and risks. Her example of professionally assisted patent filing costing R20,000 or more gave “just patent it” the financial weight missing from casual entrepreneurial advice.

Benefit-sharing arrangements could recognise inventors and support future innovation. The report carefully identifies the royalty and milestone figures discussed as examples, not universal promises. Readers hoping to calculate their fortune from one webinar must therefore return to the less glamorous business of reading their own institution’s policy.

The form remembers what the success story forgets

The invention disclosure form asks what problem is being solved, how the solution works and who contributed. These are modest questions with revolutionary potential, particularly the last one.

Galada’s hypothetical medicinal-plant example recognised community knowledge alongside laboratory work. A community’s contribution should not evaporate at precisely the moment its knowledge becomes commercially interesting. The scientific equipment may be sophisticated, but it should not function as a machine for making earlier contributors disappear.

External innovators also bring “background” intellectual property into collaborations, while new work may generate “foreground” intellectual property. The terminology sounds like stage design, but the distinction matters. Otherwise, someone enters the university carrying an invention and leaves carrying a visitor’s badge and a warm sense of partnership.

Clear agreements are not the enemy of trust. They are what trust wears when money may eventually enter the room.

The entrepreneur is not automatically included

Commercialisation offers several routes: licensing, spin-outs, partnerships, joint ventures and, in some circumstances, assignment. The route depends on policy, readiness, resources and the people involved. There is no universal conveyor belt on which a thesis enters at one end and a profitable company emerges at the other.

A spin-out needs management, governance and funding. These requirements can surprise researchers whose chief qualification for running a business is having invented the thing the business would sell.

The panel acknowledged that technical brilliance and commercial leadership are different abilities. This should not be controversial, yet institutional enthusiasm occasionally treats a doctorate as a combined certificate in discovery, sales, payroll and investor relations.

An experienced entrepreneur might be the appropriate partner. Retaining total control of an invention that never reaches anyone is certainly a form of ownership, but an unusually solitary one. The founder has complete authority over an organisation whose principal customer remains the founder.

The market regrets it was not consulted

An audience contribution supplied one of the discussion’s most useful interruptions: were potential buyers involved early, or merely approached for money after the solution had been completed?

This question threatens an elegant research workflow. First identify a fascinating problem. Then secure funding, conduct the research and develop a solution. Finally, locate someone whose daily life can be persuaded to resemble the original proposal.

Early user engagement reverses this arrangement. It asks researchers to encounter actual needs before becoming emotionally attached to their answers. Users may introduce awkward concerns such as affordability, maintenance, working conditions and whether the innovation solves the problem they actually have.

Galada’s road-maintenance example showed why a recognised problem does not guarantee adoption. Government, contractors and purchasing arrangements can matter as much as technical performance. A pothole may be entirely convinced that it needs fixing; unfortunately, the pothole is not the procurement authority.

The valley of death has excellent presentation facilities Rapuleng described the early commercial period often called the “valley of death”, when a technology may generate little income and struggle for support. Innovation policy deserves credit for finding a geographical metaphor frank enough to discourage casual sightseeing. At conferences, this valley is often crossed by an arrow. In practice, the arrow needs money, testing, capable people and someone willing to buy the result. It cannot live indefinitely on the phrase “high growth potential”.

Licensing too early may leave an entrepreneur carrying an opportunity that cannot yet attract funding. Protecting inventions in countries without plausible markets may also consume scarce resources. The sensible response is strategic timing and market analysis, not a heroic expansion of paperwork.

Continental markets offer opportunity, but the report notes that national IP systems still matter. The African Continental Free Trade Area does not magically turn every commercial boundary into an open door. Ambition may travel widely; legal advice still needs an itinerary.

Counting patents: an excellent way to produce patents The discussion of performance measures exposed a familiar administrative miracle. Tell an office that success means more patent filings, and it may produce more patent filings. Whether anybody subsequently uses the inventions is a separate field on a different spreadsheet.

Galada argued that a small number of commercially used patents could matter more than a large inactive portfolio. This introduces a dangerous complication into reporting: outcomes. Jobs, viable ventures, adoption and social benefit are harder to count than applications. They also have the unsettling advantage of describing things people might actually care about. A beautifully protected invention sitting unused is still sitting unused; it simply has stronger documentation.

Resources matter too. Comparing offices without considering their staffing and investment is rather like comparing ambulance response times while declining to ask which team has an ambulance. Institutions cannot reasonably demand a sophisticated commercial pipeline and supply only optimism, a shared inbox and an annual target. \

Begin in school, before the habits become permanent The report also brought schools and informal innovators into view. A contribution from a 17-year-old student from Morocco reinforced the argument for introducing these questions before university, rather than presenting intellectual property as a graduation surprise. This need not mean turning primary school into a miniature patent practice. It means helping young people understand problems, customers, contributions and the practical consequences of sharing or protecting work.

Informal innovators likewise should not need an academic title before their ingenuity becomes institutionally visible. Incubators, entrepreneurship centres and research partnerships can offer routes to support, provided the welcome comes with clarity about rights.

Looking towards 2036, the discussion challenged universities to connect education with workplace realities. Expecting unemployed graduates suddenly to become entrepreneurs is not a curriculum. It is an emergency exit marked “be resilient”. Students need practical learning before the labour market asks them to improvise an entire livelihood. 11. Next steps: a webinar about leaving the webinar

The closing announcements included another webinar, a call for book chapters and a written account. There is an unavoidable comic beauty in responding to the need to move beyond publications and discussion with further publications and discussion.

Thw webinar's suggested next steps include early IP and user-needs reviews, demonstration projects, stronger commercial teams, clearer agreements and measures tied to actual use. It also explicitly distinguishes these proposals from agreed commitments. Nobody has secretly approved a budget merely by attending politely.

The evening’s imaginary dinner and suggestion of future food vouchers offered a final miniature lesson in impact: announcing nourishment is not the same as delivering it. That is ultimately the report’s serious point. Research does not become useful because everyone agrees that usefulness is important. Someone must clarify the rights, test the solution, assemble the team and secure adoption. Until then, “research to impact” remains an excellent title for a document about the journey. The next breakthrough would be arriving

Have something to say? Let's make sure it's understood.

Tell me what you're working on. I'll give you an honest view of how I can help — and what it takes to get it done.